Does closing a credit card hurt your credit?
Key points
- Closing a card can lower your score mainly because it removes available credit, which raises your credit utilization ratio. That matters most if you carry balances on other cards.
- Your history doesn't vanish right away. FICO generally counts both open and closed accounts in the length of your credit history, and a closed account in good standing often stays on your report for about 10 years.
- If the reason is an annual fee, ask about a product change to a no-fee card first. If you do close, pay the balance, cancel autopays and check your credit reports afterward.
Closing a credit card can hurt your credit, but usually not because of the reason people expect. The biggest effect is on your credit utilization: you lose that card's credit limit, so the balances on your other cards take up a bigger share of the credit you have left. The CFPB says the change may be temporary or minor, and that the full impact depends on the rest of your credit profile.
If you have no balances anywhere, closing a card may barely matter. If you carry debt on other cards, it can matter a lot. Below is the math, a worked example, and a checklist for closing a card the safe way.
Why closing a card can lower your score
FICO groups the information in your credit report into five categories. According to myFICO, payment history counts for about 35% of a FICO Score, amounts owed 30%, length of credit history 15%, credit mix 10% and new credit 10%. Closing a card can touch three of these.
1. Credit utilization goes up
Your utilization ratio is the amount you owe on your cards divided by your total credit limits. The CFPB explains that closing an existing card can increase this ratio and lower your score. myFICO calls the ratio one of the most important factors in your FICO Score, and notes that closing an unused card wipes away some of your available credit and causes the ratio to increase.
Utilization = total card balances ÷ total credit limits × 100The balance doesn't change when you close a card. Only the bottom of the fraction gets smaller, so the percentage rises. You can test your own numbers with the credit utilization calculator.
2. Length of credit history (eventually)
This is where a lot of advice gets it wrong. myFICO says FICO Scores generally consider the age of both open and closed accounts, and that as long as an account remains on your credit report, it may factor into your length of credit history. So closing an old card usually doesn't shorten your history the day you close it.
The effect comes later. myFICO says closed accounts in good standing are often removed after around 10 years. Once that old card leaves your report, it can no longer help this part of your score, which is worth about 15%. Citi gives the same timeline: an account closed in good standing can stay on your report for up to 10 years, while accounts closed with missed payments typically remain for seven years.
3. Credit mix
Citi lists credit mix as the third factor a closed card can affect. If that card is your only revolving account, closing it leaves you with no open credit cards, which narrows your mix. For most people with several cards, this is the smallest of the three effects.
A worked example: what happens to utilization
Say you have three cards and carry a balance on one of them:
- Card A: your oldest card, $6,000 limit, $1,800 balance.
- Card B: a card with an annual fee, $3,000 limit, $0 balance.
- Card C: your newest card, $2,000 limit, $0 balance, rarely used.
Today your total limit is $6,000 + $3,000 + $2,000 = $11,000, and you owe $1,800. Your utilization is $1,800 ÷ $11,000 = 16.36%. Here's what closing each card does, assuming the $1,800 balance stays the same:
| Scenario | Total limits | Balances | Utilization |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keep all three open | $11,000 | $1,800 | 16.36% |
| Close Card C | $9,000 | $1,800 | 20.00% |
| Close Card B | $8,000 | $1,800 | 22.50% |
| Close Cards B and C | $6,000 | $1,800 | 30.00% |
Closing the two zero-balance cards nearly doubles utilization, from 16.36% to 30.00%, without a single new dollar of debt. U.S. Bank notes that experts usually recommend keeping utilization below 30%, and this move takes you right up to that line.
How much to pay down first
You can offset the jump by lowering the balance before you close. To keep utilization at 16.36% after closing Card B, the balance can be at most 16.36% of the remaining $8,000 limit:
$1,800 ÷ $11,000 × $8,000 = $1,309.09 → pay down $1,800 − $1,309.09 = $490.91To get to 10% instead, the balance would need to be $800 (10% of $8,000), which means paying down $1,000. Run your own cards through the utilization calculator to see the before and after.
Which card is safer to close?
When you're choosing between cards, a few questions help:
- Which has the smallest limit? A small limit removes less available credit, so utilization rises less. In the example, closing Card C costs less than closing Card B.
- Which is the oldest? An old account in good standing keeps helping your length of history while it's open. The CFPB notes that some people keep an old account open, especially one with a positive payment history, because it may help maintain a higher score.
- Which costs you money? A card whose annual fee or terms outweigh what you get from it is the classic reason to close, per the CFPB.
- Does it carry a balance? Closing a card doesn't erase what you owe. Citi notes that you still have to make monthly payments until the balance is paid off, and U.S. Bank says to keep paying on time. A late payment on a closed card still hurts.
When closing a card can make sense
Keeping a card open isn't always the right call. The CFPB says closing a card might be a good decision if:
- The card has annual fees or poor terms that outweigh the benefits.
- It helps you avoid building up debt you can't pay off.
- You aren't planning to apply for credit in the near future.
myFICO adds another case: a joint account during a separation or divorce. Timing matters too. If you plan to apply for a mortgage or car loan soon, a temporary dip could affect the rate you're offered, so some people wait until after the loan closes.
Alternatives to closing
- Ask for a product change. If the annual fee is the problem, ask your issuer about switching to one of its no-fee cards. U.S. Bank says a product change usually lets you keep the original account history on your credit report. myFICO also mentions downgrading as an option. Not every issuer or card allows it.
- Ask about the fee. myFICO's advice on high-fee cards starts with whether the issuer will waive the fee.
- Keep it open and use it lightly. myFICO warns that issuers can close accounts for inactivity. U.S. Bank suggests putting one small recurring bill on the card with autopay so it stays active.
- Put it away. If the worry is overspending, some people remove the card from their phone wallet and online stores instead of closing it. Keep checking the statements: the CFPB recommends watching an unused account for fraud and unexpected fees.
How to close a credit card the safe way
- Pay the balance to zero if you can. Citi recommends paying off existing debt before closing.
- Use your rewards. Redeem points or cash back first, since you may lose them when the account closes.
- Move recurring bills. Switch subscriptions and autopays to another card.
- Check your utilization. Run the numbers with and without the card's limit, as in the example above.
- Call or message the issuer and ask for written confirmation that the account is closed.
- Check your credit reports. Citi suggests checking about 30 days later, and U.S. Bank says to confirm the account shows as "closed at customer request." The CFPB says you can get free reports once a week at AnnualCreditReport.com.
- Shred the card.
If you're still building credit, see how to build credit from scratch. And since utilization is based on what your issuer reports, statement balance vs. current balance explains which number counts.
Sources
- CFPB: Does it hurt my credit to close a credit card?
- CFPB: How do I get a free copy of my credit reports?
- myFICO: What's in my FICO Scores?
- myFICO: How to decide whether it's time to close a credit card
- myFICO: Relationship between credit cards and credit scores
- Citi: Does closing a credit card hurt your credit?
- U.S. Bank: Does closing a credit card hurt your score?
Frequently asked questions
Does closing a credit card with a zero balance hurt my credit?
It can. Even with a $0 balance, the card's limit counts toward your total available credit. Closing it raises your utilization if you carry balances on other cards.
Does a closed credit card still count toward my credit history?
Generally yes, under FICO. myFICO says FICO Scores consider the age of both open and closed accounts while they remain on your report, and closed accounts in good standing are often removed after around 10 years.
Do I still have to pay a balance on a closed card?
Yes. Closing the account doesn't cancel the debt. You keep making at least the monthly payment, on time, until the balance is paid off.
Is it better to downgrade a card than close it?
If your issuer offers a product change to a no-fee card, it usually lets you keep the original account history on your credit report and avoids losing that account entirely. Not every issuer or card allows it.